The short answer

There’s no official “pass” or “fail” score in most employment background checks. The screening company reports what it finds, and the employer decides. In practice, problems usually come from one of three things:

  1. A record that matters for the job, such as a recent conviction related to the role, a serious driving record for a driving job, or a professional license that’s suspended.
  2. Information that doesn’t match what you wrote, such as different dates, job titles, employer names or degrees.
  3. Something that can’t be verified, such as a past employer that won’t respond or a school that can’t confirm your degree.

The third kind is often fixable with documents, and the second is often an honest mistake you can explain.

Common red flags on a background check

Red flag Why employers care What you can do Learn more
Criminal conviction related to the job Safety, trust or legal rules for the role Know your record, give context, check fair chance rights Criminal records and jobs
Pending charges Unresolved case Know your state’s rules on pending cases Pending charges
Employment dates or titles that don’t match Looks like an inaccurate application Use exact dates; explain differences Date or title discrepancy
Employer can’t verify the job Can’t confirm your history Send W-2s, pay stubs or a letter Unable to verify employment
Degree can’t be verified or doesn’t exist Fake or unaccredited degrees are a serious issue Confirm your degree record first Education verification
Identity mismatch Name, birth date or SSN doesn’t line up Use your legal name and correct details SSN trace
Driving record problems For driving jobs, a suspension or DUI matters Check your MVR before applying MVR checks
Failed or refused drug test Many employers require a negative test Know the process and your rights Failed drug test
Credit issues (some finance jobs) Some roles check credit Check your credit report first Credit checks
Lying on the application Dishonesty is often treated worse than the record itself Answer exactly what’s asked The conviction question

Does a criminal record automatically make you fail?

No. The EEOC’s guidance says employers should consider the nature and seriousness of the offense, how long ago it was, and how it relates to the job. Many states and cities also have fair chance laws that require an individual look at your situation. See the EEOC’s arrest and conviction records page.

Some jobs do have legal disqualifiers, for example certain health care, child care, financial or transportation roles. Those rules are set by law, not by the employer’s preference.

What can’t make you fail on its own

  • An arrest that didn’t lead to a conviction. The EEOC says an arrest alone doesn’t prove someone did something. See arrests on background checks.
  • Old non-conviction records beyond the FCRA’s seven-year reporting limit for most jobs.
  • A sealed or expunged record where your state’s law restricts its use. See sealed and expunged records.

How to know your red flags before the employer does

  1. Check court records in each county and state where you’ve lived.
  2. Confirm your exact employment dates and titles with W-2s, pay stubs or your Social Security earnings record.
  3. Confirm your degree with your school or the National Student Clearinghouse.
  4. Check your driving record if the job involves driving.
  5. Request your free file from screening companies that hold reports about you.

Before you dispute, you may want to see your current records at the official sources, identify the exact discrepancy and gather the official records that prove it. The Self Check Guide shows you how to do exactly that, step by step.

If you’re told you failed

You’re entitled to a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report before the decision is final. Use that window to fix errors and explain. See failed a background check after a job offer?

What the law says about using your background report

Federal law shapes how employers use what they find. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), an employer must get your permission before ordering a background report, and must send a pre-adverse action notice before rejecting you because of it. You then get a few business days to respond. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) also warns employers against blanket bans based on criminal history, and asks them to consider each person’s circumstances.

In practice, most employers make the background check part of a conditional job offer. That means the job offer stands unless something in your criminal history, credit history, employment verification or job application raises a real concern.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most common reason people fail a background check?

There isn’t one official list, but mismatched employment details, unverifiable history and criminal records related to the job come up often.

Will I pass a background check with a misdemeanor?

Often, yes, depending on the offense, how old it is and the job. See misdemeanors on background checks.

Can a small date mistake make me fail?

Usually not by itself, but it can delay your check or raise questions. Fix it quickly with proof.

Does a background check show if I was fired?

It can, depending on what the employer reports. See does a background check show if you were fired?

What can cause you to fail a background check?

The most common reasons are a criminal record that relates to the job, false or mismatched information on your application, a driving record that doesn’t meet the job’s rules, a failed drug test, or a missing license. Many problems turn out to be errors or mismatches that can be fixed.

How do I fix my background check?

If the problem is an error, get a copy of your report and dispute it with the screening company, with proof. If the record is accurate, look into whether it can be sealed or expunged, and prepare a short, honest explanation for employers. See background check errors.

Official Sources and Further Reading

Related criminal record guides: probation vs. parole, do felonies go away?, passports with a felony and traffic tickets on background checks.

Your next step

Most red flags can be found, and many fixed, before you apply. That’s the whole point of checking yourself first.

The Employment Background Check Self-Check Guide walks you through each official source so you can see your red flags before an employer does.

Get the $47 Signature Edition (Guide + Bonus AI Toolkit)